Can Blue Apron Really Get My Picky Eater to, Well, Eat? My Kitchen Confessions

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Purchases through these links support our site at no extra cost to you.

Okay, real talk: my kitchen often feels like a battlefield. Trying to get my kids to eat anything beyond chicken nuggets and plain pasta is a daily Olympic sport. So, when I started seeing all the ads for Blue Apron, with their beautiful, diverse meals, I had to wonder: could Blue Apron actually get my picky eater to, well, eat? I mean, a girl can dream, right? I signed up, skeptically optimistic, and dove headfirst into a few months of delivered dinners, hoping for a miracle in a box. Here’s what actually happened.

Blue Apron’s Menu: A Picky Eater’s Minefield or a Hidden Gem?

First off, let’s talk about the menu. Every week, Blue Apron offers a bunch of different recipes, usually around 10-12 options, plus some add-ons. They’ve got your classic meat-and-potatoes, some fish dishes, and usually a couple of vegetarian options. And sometimes, they’ll have a ‘family-friendly’ tag on a recipe, which I always eyed suspiciously. Like, what does ‘family-friendly’ even mean to a 7-year-old who thinks broccoli is poison? Honestly, I wasn’t expecting miracles from their standard lineup for my incredibly particular crew. They do let you swap proteins on some meals, which is kinda neat if you’re trying to avoid red meat or something, but it doesn’t really help when the whole *concept* of the meal is the issue.

Navigating the ‘Customization’ for Tiny Taste Buds

You can pick your meals a week or two in advance, which is good. I’d sit there, scrolling, trying to find anything that didn’t have ‘sauce’ or ‘vegetable medley’ in the description. My strategy quickly became: find the most deconstructed-looking meal possible. Think a simple chicken breast with a side of rice, or maybe a pasta dish where I could easily pick out the offending ingredients. It’s not true customization, but it’s what I worked with.

My Real-World Blue Apron Wins (and Epic Fails) with the Kids

Okay, so here’s the juicy part. I ordered for about three months, getting three meals a week for four people (my husband, me, and two kids). The cost was around $79.99 to $89.99 a week, depending on the specific meals chosen. Some weeks, it was a total bust. I remember this one time we got a ‘Spicy Pork & Kimchi Stir-Fry.’ Bless their hearts, Blue Apron, but my kids took one look at the kimchi and acted like I’d served them actual garbage. They ate plain rice and a banana that night. Total fail. But then, there were these unexpected wins, you know? Like the ‘Crispy Chicken with Roasted Sweet Potatoes and Green Beans.’ I just served the chicken plain to them, put the sweet potatoes on the side, and told them the green beans were ‘tree branches.’ My oldest actually ate a few. A FEW! I nearly fell out of my chair. And the ‘Cheesy Chicken & Broccoli Pasta Bake’? I just picked out the broccoli for their plates, and they devoured the rest. It wasn’t perfect, but it was *something* different that wasn’t frozen pizza.

The Unexpected Victories: When They *Actually* Ate It

The biggest wins usually involved familiar proteins prepared simply. Anything with pasta was a safe bet, as long as the sauce wasn’t too ‘weird.’ The ‘Smoky Chicken & Corn Chowder’ was a surprise hit – I think the corn and the creamy broth made it appealing. And honestly, the novelty of the little ingredient bags sometimes got them curious enough to try a bite, even if it was just for the novelty.

My Sneaky Mom Strategies for Making Blue Apron Work (Sort Of)

Look, if you’re serious about trying Blue Apron with a picky eater, you gotta have a game plan. My biggest tip? Deconstruct everything. If the recipe calls for mixing sauce into pasta, I’d cook the pasta, cook the sauce, and serve them separately. My kids would get plain pasta, plain chicken, and maybe a tiny dab of sauce on the side for ‘dipping’ if they were feeling brave. I’d also always have a backup plan, like some emergency frozen peas or a simple grilled cheese, just in case dinner was a complete meltdown. Don’t be afraid to deviate from the recipe. Blue Apron gives you the ingredients; you’re the boss of how they end up on the plate. Sometimes, I’d even use their protein for the kids and make a completely different, simpler side for them, while my husband and I enjoyed the full Blue Apron meal. It’s all about damage control, right?

Bending the Rules: Adapting Recipes for Sanity’s Sake

I’d often serve the components separately. Chicken on one part of the plate, rice on another, and the vegetable (if I even bothered offering it to them) in a tiny separate bowl. Sometimes, I’d ‘hide’ finely chopped veggies in sauces for my husband and me, while the kids got the plain version. It’s a bit more work, but it saved me from the nightly dinner drama.

Is the Blue Apron Price Tag Worth the Picky Eater Headache?

So, the big question: is it worth the money? For a family of four, we were spending around $80-90 a week for three meals. That works out to about $6.60 to $7.50 per serving. Honestly, for the convenience of not having to meal plan or grocery shop for those three dinners, it’s not bad. Especially since grocery prices at places like Walmart and even Costco have been wild lately. But here’s the thing: if your *sole* goal is to get a truly picky eater to suddenly embrace gourmet food, you might be disappointed. It’s not a magic bullet. It definitely introduced *me* to some new recipes and flavors, and it took the stress out of *my* cooking for a few nights, which was a huge win. But for the kids, it was more about strategic adaptation than a culinary revolution. Would I do it again? Yeah, probably, but with eyes wide open about the picky eater situation.

The Cost vs. Convenience for Challenging Dinners

For me, the value came from the mental break. Not having to think, ‘What’s for dinner tonight?’ three times a week was priceless. The ingredients are good quality, usually fresh from their suppliers, and the portions are decent. It’s not necessarily cheaper than grocery shopping at Trader Joe’s and cooking from scratch, but it saves time and brainpower.

⭐ Pro Tips

• Always have a backup meal: a box of Annie’s mac and cheese or some simple scrambled eggs can save your sanity when a Blue Apron meal goes sideways.
• Deconstruct everything: serve sauces on the side, keep proteins plain for the kids, and offer veggies separately. Don’t mix it all up if you know they’ll reject it.
• Involve them in a tiny way: let them wash a veggie or stir something simple. Sometimes ownership (even tiny) can lead to a bite.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

So, here’s my honest take on Blue Apron for picky eaters: it’s not a magic solution that will turn your kid into a gourmet food lover overnight. You’re still going to have to do some work, some deconstructing, and maybe offer a few ’emergency’ dinners. But what it *does* offer is a fantastic break for *you*. It brings new, interesting recipes into your rotation (for the adults!), saves you time on planning and shopping, and might, just might, get your picky eater to try a bite of something new. For me, that little bit of peace of mind was totally worth it. Give it a try, but go in with a realistic game plan!