We Tried the Most Famous Foods on Goldbelly: Is It Worth the Hype?

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. Purchases through these links support our site at no extra cost to you.

Okay so I’ve been eyeing Goldbelly for ages, you know? That site where you can get legit New York bagels delivered to, like, your door in Arizona? Wild. So I finally bit the bullet and ordered some of the most famous foods on Goldbelly. I’m talking iconic stuff. Was it worth the $$? Or just an expensive gimmick? I’ve got the real tea for you, from my kitchen to yours, with all the messy details.

The Iconic New York Pizza: Lombardi’s

First up, gotta talk pizza. I ordered a classic Margherita from Lombardi’s, supposedly the first pizzeria in the US. It arrived in a fancy insulated box, looking pretty legit. The crust had that good char, cheese was melted, basil fresh. It’s definitely not *exactly* like eating it hot out of the oven in NYC, but it’s shockingly close. The biggest bummer? Trying to get it into my oven to reheat without ruining it. It’s a whole operation.

Reheating Lombardi’s Pizza Like a Pro

Okay, so the directions say just pop it in the oven. But that can dry it out. I found preheating my oven to 450°F (230°C) with a pizza stone inside worked best. Slide the pizza on, bake for 5-7 minutes until the cheese is bubbly and the crust is crispy again. Don’t walk away! It happens fast.

Deep Dish Disaster (or Delight?) from Chicago: Lou Malnati’s

Next, the deep dish. I went with Lou Malnati’s because everyone raves about it. This thing is a beast. It arrived, still surprisingly warm, and the smell alone was amazing. The crust is buttery, the sausage is chunky and delicious, and that tomato sauce on top? Chef’s kiss. Real talk: it’s heavy. Like, a lot of food. You’ll probably only eat one slice and feel stuffed for days. Worth it? Yes, but maybe order a smaller one unless you have a pizza party planned.

Serving Lou Malnati’s Deep Dish

This isn’t your thin-crust situation. You need a good, sturdy knife and a wide spatula. Let it sit for about 10 minutes after you take it out of the oven (if reheating) before attempting to cut. It helps everything set just a bit so it doesn’t collapse into a cheesy mess.

Sweet Treats: Magnolia Bakery’s Banana Pudding

Okay, I’m a sucker for good dessert. Magnolia Bakery’s banana pudding is legendary. It came in a little plastic tub, and honestly, it looked exactly like the pictures. The layers of vanilla wafers, fresh bananas, and that creamy, dreamy pudding? So good. It’s sweet, but not cloyingly so. The wafers get perfectly soft but still have a little bite. If you’re a banana pudding fan, this is a must-try. Way better than any store-bought stuff I’ve had.

Magnolia Pudding: Eat it Cold!

This is one of those things you just eat straight from the container with a spoon. It’s meant to be served cold. Seriously, don’t even think about warming it up. Just grab a spoon and dig in. It’s pure comfort food.

Savory Snacks: Gus’s Fried Chicken

I had to try some fried chicken, and Gus’s from Memphis is always on these ‘best of’ lists. It arrived in a cardboard box, and the chicken pieces were still warm and smelled incredible. The crust is perfectly crispy, not greasy, and the chicken inside was juicy. It has a nice little kick of spice, too. It’s definitely premium fried chicken, and you can taste the difference. A bit pricey, but for a special treat? I’d do it again.

Keeping Gus’s Fried Chicken Crispy

Fried chicken loses its magic when it gets soggy. If you’re reheating, use your oven or an air fryer on a medium heat (around 375°F/190°C) for a few minutes. Avoid the microwave at all costs – it turns it into rubbery sadness.

⭐ Pro Tips

• Order on a Monday or Tuesday to avoid weekend shipping delays. Goldbelly often ships from businesses that close on Sundays.
• Check for deals! Goldbelly sometimes offers free shipping or discounts. Sign up for their newsletter. I saved $30 on my pizza order last month.
• Don’t expect it to taste *exactly* like it did when it was made fresh. Shipping is tough on food. Manage your expectations, especially for delicate items.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

So, the verdict on famous foods on Goldbelly? It’s a mixed bag, but mostly a good one. It’s definitely a splurge, but getting a taste of a famous spot you can’t visit is pretty cool. Just be smart about what you order and how you reheat it. If you’ve got a special occasion or just want to treat yourself, go for it!